ijiblog.net, by Larry Ingram, publishes media and news analysis

Disciple-maker Jeff Vandersteldt and the epidemic of imaginative Old and New Testament doctrine

4/17/2016

 
Disciple-making is an important aspect of the Bible, since Jesus commanded people to follow him. And Christians are known for being followers or disciples of Jesus. But the word disciple-making becomes a problem when teachers like Jeff Vanderstelt claim that disciple-making was not exclusive to the New Testament, but occurred in the Old Testament as well.
Disciple-making is an important aspect of the Bible, since Jesus commanded people to follow him. And Christians are known for being followers or disciples of Jesus. But the word disciple-making becomes a problem when teachers like Jeff Vanderstelt claim that disciple-making was not exclusive to the New Testament, but occurred in the Old Testament as well. It amounts to a watering down of the Bible, or a misguided attempt to essentially spread Jesus through the Bible. By using the word disciple more often, and seeing it where it is not, more people will somehow come to know Jesus and more will be his disciples. That's the idea, however misguided it may be.
The message is that what Jesus said in the New Testament was not really enough. We don’t get enough of Jesus modeling what it looks like to be a Christian from the four people who wrote the gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, or what the Apostle Paul wrote about becoming a Christian in the New Testament. We need to talk about it in the Old Testament as well. People are not smart enough to get it in the New Testament, so let's make up things in the Old Testament.
There are many charismatic type teachers who claim extra revelation or a word from the Lord; they claim extra revelation, or adding to the Bible. Benny Hinn is one that comes to mind. But they are not taken seriously by Bible scholars. Though Vandersteldt may not be taken seriously by Bible scholars (at least his speaking about disciple-making in the Old Testament), he is taken seriously by pastors in the Acts 29 group of churches, which uses a Reformed theology as a foundation for preaching God’s word.
In fact, Vanderstelt was at an Acts 29 conference in St. Louis, where he used animals, plants and Adam and Eve as examples of disciple-making. There is no reference to disciple-making or being a follow of Adam of Eve or Cain or Able, or Noah or anyone else in the Old Testament. The fact that Adam and Eve brought sin into the world does not mean that everyone after them became followers of Adam and Eve. We have a sin nature because of what they did in the garden.
Inanimate plants and animals do not have followers
That’s why there is no reference to the world followers similar to following Jesus in the Old Testament. David had followers, but not disciples as Jesus had the disciples. David pointed people to the God of the Old Testament, not to himself. If he did not, he would not have been referred to a man after God's own heart.
Is there a difference between having influence over someone and being a disciple? One can influence someone, and be popular, as many political figures are today. They may have more influence over of us. But rarely do they claim to demand devotion or a following as Jesus did. They don't usually claim to be God either.
The term disciple is derived from the Koine Greek word mathetes, which means a pupil of a teacher or an apprentice. One could also use it to refer to someone who learns or a student.
In a secular sense, there are many disciples, thousands if not millions, since there are many students attending school. But are they seeking to emulate a life style in the way that disciples seek to model themselves after Jesus or other believers?
Is emulating the sin nature, in the Old Testament, the same as being a disciple of Jesus, or is it just something that is in our sin nature? According to the Bible, it’s clearly not the same thing. Neither is it the same thing as a tree or a weed that reproduces to become what the seed dictates that it will become. If that were the case, why would Jesus or the Apostle Paul make such a big deal about being different from the sin nature? In fact, much of what Paul talks about in the New Testament highlights the difference between being a Christian and obeying the sin nature. One should ask, is the sin nature a good example of how we disciple each other, or what we are called to?
Trees are disciple-makers as well
“Everyone is a disciple maker,” Vandersteldt says. “Including trees. Trees are disciple makers as well."
Of course, this is not the case. Vandersteldt confuses the void that is present in our lives with making the effort to follow someone, like a leader, a teacher or Jesus. The opposite is actually the case; it takes discipline that is completely outside the sin nature and what is natural to be a disciple of Jesus. This is clear in the New Testament.
For Vandersteldt, being a disciple is what the animals and plants do.
“In Genesis, we see God  making trees that will have fruit,” he says. “In the fruit will be seeds. And the animals will do the same thing. And he tells Adam and Eve to multiply and fill the earth.”
Part of multiplying is having sex, which results in procreation and filling the earth. Are we to understand that being a disciple is the same as having sex? Diluting the meaning of making disciples is really missing the narrative of the Bible. Even more so, to say that becoming a follower of Jesus is similar to plants and animals reproducing to be more plants and animals doesn’t make sense. Jesus said just the opposite, if we are to believe the gospels:
The Cost of Following Jesus: Luke 9:57, 58:
"As they were going along the road, someone said to Him, "I will follow You wherever You go." And Jesus said to him, "The foxes have holes and the birds of the air have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay His head."
Vandersteldt is part of an increasingly popular group that attempts to create something new, by coining a few phrases
Here are a few:
Mission, Missional, On Mission
Gospel, gospel-centered
Gathering
Multipy, Multiplication
While none of these words are harmful in and of themselves, it's how they are used that causes problems when interpreting and teaching the Bible, and being the church.
Here is a statement from gcmcollective (part of Soma Communities):
The GCM Collective exists to promote, create and equip Gospel Communities on Mission. A gospel community is a group of believers that lives out the mission of God together as family, in a specific area to a particular people group, by declaring and demonstrating the gospel in tangible forms.  Regular people, living ordinary lives, with great gospel intentionality.
Ask someone associated with this movement what gospel intentionality means, and it’s not clear that it is the same thing as in the Bible. The inference is that people who do not use “gospel intentionality” are not really acting out the gospel.
One pastor in the Acts 29 group of churches used the word gospel more than 50 times as part of his sermon. Clearly there seems to be an assumption that if one uses the word gospel more often, it means that one is more centered on Jesus or simply more aware of Jesus' mission. If this were the case, why would Paul not have encouraged Christians to do this?
To be sure, Vandersteldt talks about some things that definitely make sense, like the fact that Christians in the U.S. need to have the mindset that they are sent into the U.S., as Christians, in same way that missionaries being sent overseas.
“(We) wanted to live life on mission, in the every day, not just every day Sunday for a couple of hours,” he says in a video about Soma Communities in Tacoma, WA.
He asks the question, “Who has God sent us to?”
The idea is to radically re-orient ones life to reach non-believers and other Christians who are disaffected. The problem is that this is mostly a popular gospel that rarely challenges people with their political or world-views that affect people. The gospel of Soma community, in essence, does not extend this far.
Seattle, where Vandersteldt's church is based, is known as one of the more progressive or liberal (read Godless) states in the U.S., and was labeled as such by none other than Bernie Sanders when he visited the city (before he was cut off from his speech by Black Lives Matter activists). This mission field for churches like Soma usually does not extend to talking about issues that affect non-Christians and Christians alike - especially political issues. The reason is that it's not popular, certainly not in Seattle.
One adherent to Soma says:
“This is what the gospel is about. This is what it means to say Jesus is my Lord and Savior.”
But is that really the case? The corollary is: if you are not doing this, Jesus is not your Lord and Savior. All Christians have a higher calling to follow Jesus. But if one does not do these things, does it mean that they are not Christians?
Soma and Vandersteldt also don't like the word Bible study
“You can have a Bible study and be unfaithful to the scriptures,” he says. “They don’t lead to a healthy and effective church.”
Bible studies stop, they don’t create the church, Vanderstelt says in the video. “They often think the goal was to study the Bible instead of becoming a healthy family.”
The obvious problem with this is that Paul actually commended a group of believers for “searching the scriptures” or studying the Bible.
Acts 17:11: "Now the Berean Jews were of more noble character than those in Thessalonica, for they received the message with great eagerness and examined the Scriptures every day to see if what Paul said was true."
The result is that many of them became believers because of their persistence in studying the Bible. Further, if Christians are not motivated to study the Bible, why would non-believers?
The better question, which Vandersteldt does not ask, is, if studying the Bible does not make one relevant as a believer, why not?  One church, The Journey in St. Louis, was founded, by Darrin Patrick, and grew because of the concept of expository preaching - relevant and well-communicated expository preaching - but still, expository preaching.
In fact, intense and open study of New Testament books like Corinthians, where sin is openly discussed is probably why The Journey flourished. Added to that was the assumption that people hearing the message would discover it themselves. The idea is to present such a compelling message that people would want to read about it in the Bible.
The jettisoning of Bible study in small groups, community groups, can result in only the pastor studying the Bible: a pastor of a church can study the Bible, but people on mission don’t really need to study the Bible.
Pastors like Vandersteldt, others in the Acts 29 group as well as other pastors, may prepare for a sermon between four and 16 hours, or a half day to two full days. Any more than that can be counter productive. Church members, on average, often spend very little time actually studying the Bible, to the consternation of many pastors. If a pastor says that they are not meeting to study the Bible when they meet together, the result can be similar to what happened in the Middle Ages - common every day people were discouraged from reading the Bible.
If a teacher or pastor wants Christ followers to be like the New Testament church, does he tell believers not to study the Bible? Is that how we get believers to become more authentic?
“We really think that Jesus came to die to give us more than a great sermon and good music on Sunday morning,” says one Soma member. “He died so that our whole life could be restored to God. The Gospel comes to bear on all parts of your life, as you’re living in community. It’s messy and it’s uncomfortable and it’s scary.”
“This is what missional living is about,” says Vanderstelt’s wife, Jayne. “It’s not this nice, clean tidy wipe my hands at the end of the day and push people out and live my own life. It becomes part of who you are.”
The reality is that people in Vanderstelt’s missional church are not the only people acting like the U.S. is a mission field. They are just the only ones calling it this. Think Habitat for Humanity, the Salvation Army.
They plant a garden in the back of a neighbor’s yard. Nothing wrong with that. Lot’s good with that. But how does Vandersteldt characterize this? It’s part of getting one’s life cleaned up by the gospel. Other Christians are not doing this, therefore the gospel is not what they are demonstrating.
He also claims that this is a form of apologetics, or a defense of the gospel. But is this really what defense of the gospel means? Are Christians supposed to respond to attacks or half truths about Christianity by handing people some vegetables? Vegetables and gardens are good. But they are not the same as "defending" one's faith. This is not what Peter is referring to when he talks about be ready with an answer for your faith.
1 Peter 3:15, 16: "But in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect,16 keeping a clear conscience, so that those who speak maliciously against your good behavior in Christ may be ashamed of their slander."
What we have in reality, is the use of the word disciple and gospel according to Vandersteldt, and others at Soma Community. Teachers are held to a very high standard as he well knows. Not holding leaders accountable for what they teach, no matter how small the error, creates problems in the church now, as it has countless times in the past. Rob Bell, for one, has a brilliant and positive message of redemption and grace.
What’s wrong with Bell? His message, as one of supposed compassion, omits the aspect of God’s character as a judge who causes people to spend eternity separated from him. Other than that, he’s a great, charismatic teacher of the Bible. But that’s the problem. Mischaracterizing the Bible produces a corrupted gospel, one that does not completely depend on Jesus. We need the gospel, with a little help from a brilliant man who describes a popular and attractive church.
If we only use the word gospel more often in our conversation, it will help to make us more centered on Jesus, reminding us to be true disciples. This is the kind of gospel the church does not need. Plants and animals replicating is not part of the disciple-making process either.
© 2016 Larry Ingram

Comments are closed.

    Based in St Louis,
    ​Larry Ingram writes about the news media, movies and culture, as well as topics like race, privilege, Christianity, religious expression and tolerance.

    Many news articles are blatantly biased against Christians and conservatives in the news media, movies and culture.

    Read his exclusive articles and columns that bring balance to mainstream, leftist and liberal thinking on a variety of topics.


    Categories

    All
    Aberdeen
    Abortion
    Abortion Laws
    Abortion Restrictions
    Abortion Rights
    Abraham Lincoln
    Acts 17 Apologetics
    Adolf Hitler
    Afghanistan
    A. G. Sulzberger
    Agxplore
    Alabama
    Alexandria Ocasio Cortez
    Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
    Alyssa Milano
    American Journal Of Public Health
    Ancient Greece
    Ann Coulter
    Antifa
    April Ryan
    Arlighton Senior High School
    Atty Gen. William Barr
    Avatar
    Baby Daddies
    Baltimore
    Barach Obama
    Bayshore Progressive Democrats
    Big Bang Theory
    Bill Clinton
    Bill Moyers Journal
    Bill Nye
    Bill O'Reilly
    Bill O'Reilly
    Biologos
    Black Actors
    Black Shirts
    Bob Costas
    Bob Ewell
    Bob Woodward
    Bosnians
    Brian Stelter
    Broad Comedy
    Bryan Burwell
    Capital One
    Carmen Twillie Ambar
    Catholic Church
    Celebrity Apprentice
    Charles Darwin
    Charlie Brennan
    Chicago Police Department
    Childhood
    Children
    China
    Chrissy Tiegen
    Christine Lahti
    Climate Change
    CNN
    College Athletes
    Communism
    Communist China
    Congressional Hearing
    Corey Lewandowski
    Creation Model
    Cruella De Vil
    C-Span.org
    Cuba
    Dan Rather
    Dave Checketts
    David Cay Johnson
    Dean Baquet
    Dearborn
    Democrat National Committee
    Democrat Party
    Democrats
    Denzel Washington
    Deontay Wilder
    Department Of Justice
    Detroit
    Diane Brayton
    Diversity
    DNC
    Donald J. Trump
    Donald Trump
    Donica Thomas Varner
    Don Lemon
    Doonesbury
    Dr. Bandy Lee
    Dr. Ben Carson
    Dr. Jeffrey Sachs
    Dr. Kermit Gosnell
    Dr. Laura Schlessinger
    Dr. Leana Wen
    Dr. Martin Luther King
    Drug Smuggling
    Emory University
    Empire
    Family Research Center
    FBI
    Federal Bureau Of Investigation
    Felicity Huffman
    Fire Fighters
    Fox News
    Fox News Channel
    France
    Frank Gallagher
    Fresno Bee
    Fusion GPS
    Gar Alperovitz
    Garry Trudeau
    George Takei
    German Workers' Party
    Gertrude Stein
    Gibson's Bakery
    Glenn Beck
    Glen Simpson
    "Glory Road"
    Gov. Bill Weld
    Gov. Jay Nixon
    Great New York State Fair
    Green New Deal
    Hajib
    Hamtramck
    Harold A. Schaitberger
    Harvard University
    Hawaii
    HBO
    Hesher
    Hillary Clinton
    Hollywood
    Hollywood Celebrities
    House Intelligence Committee
    House Judiciary Committee
    Howie Kurtz
    Human Origins
    Human Trafficking
    IAFF
    Ides Of March
    Illegal Immigration
    Immanuel Christian School
    Incest
    Inner City Pastors
    Intelligent Design
    International Association Of Fire Fighters
    International Olympic Committee
    Intolerance
    Iran
    Iranian Leaders
    IRS
    Islam
    Ivanka Trump
    Jackie Robinson
    Jack Jackson
    James Cameron
    James Clapper
    James Comey
    Jason Stanley
    Jeanine Pirro
    J. Edgar Hoover
    Jennifer Garner
    Jennifer Palmieri
    Jerrold Post
    Jim Acosta
    Jim Crow
    Joe Biden
    Johnathan Van Ness
    John Brennan
    John F. Kennedy
    John Hamburg
    John Legend
    John Podesta
    John Shore
    John Wells
    Joseph Mifsud
    Joseph Romm
    Jr.
    Juan Williams
    Jubaland
    Jubaland Foundation
    Judge Jeanine
    Judiciary Committee
    Jussie Smollett
    Justin Vail
    Karen Pence
    Katie Goodman
    Kelly Robinson
    Kendrick Sampson
    Kentucky
    Ken Vogel
    Kevin Hart
    KGB
    KMOX
    Kremlin
    Lake County
    Large Hadron Collider
    Laurence Fishburne
    Leftists
    Lennox Lewis
    Leonard Pitts Jr.
    Liberal Media
    Liberals
    Li Cunxin
    Life Recovery Bible
    Lil Uzi Vert
    Lisa Randall
    Loch Ness Monster
    Los Angeles
    Lutheran
    Lynne Patton
    Lyon
    Madden 20
    MAGA
    Make America Great Again
    Mao
    March Madness
    Marek Warszawski
    Marianne Williamson
    Martin Luther King
    Martin Sheen
    Matthew McConaughey
    Megadeath
    Mendi Hasan
    Meredith Kopit Levein
    Meredith Raimondo
    Metallica
    Methane
    Mexico
    Mexico Border Crisis
    Michele Reiner
    Micron
    Mike Pence
    Mimi Alford
    Minneapolis
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Missouri
    Morality In Media
    Motherf***er
    Movie Reviews
    MSNBC
    Mueller Report
    Muslim
    Muslims
    NAACP
    National Education Association
    National Press Club
    National Public Radio
    Natural Selection
    Nazi Party
    NCAA
    Neal Conan
    Nellie Ohr
    Nelson Mandela
    Netflix
    New Testament
    New York City
    New York Times
    NFL
    Nicholas Stoller
    Nigeria
    Nobel Peace Prize
    NoDoz
    North Korea
    Npr
    NY
    Obama Administration
    Oberlin College
    Osama Bin Laden
    Oval Office
    Pastor Zhang Bike Mingxuan
    Paul Mannafort
    Persecution In China
    Peter Strzok
    Philip Zimbardo
    Planned Parenthood
    Planned Parenthood Presidential Forum
    PostTraumatic Stress Disorder
    Pres. Donald Trump
    Pres. Kennedy
    Pro Abortion
    Procter & Gamble
    Profanity
    Pro-life
    PTSD
    Purple Heart
    Pyongyang
    Racist
    Radical Left
    Ray Liota
    Rebecca Parker Mankey
    Redeemer Presbyterian Church
    Rep. Adam Schiff
    Rep. Barnis Franke
    Rep. Charles Rangel
    Rep. Darryl Issa
    Rep. Devin Nunes
    Rep. Elijah Cummings
    Rep. Ilhan Omar
    Rep. Jamie Raskin
    Rep. Jerold Nadler
    Rep Jerrold Nadler
    Rep. John Radcliffe
    Rep. John Shimkus
    Rep. Ken Buck
    Rep. Mark Meadows
    Rep. Maxine Waters
    Rep. Nancy Pelosi
    Rep. Rashida Tlaib
    Reproductive Rights
    Rep. Shirley Jackson Lee
    Rep. Steve Cohen
    Rep. Steve Scalise
    Republicans
    Rev Al Sharpton
    Rev. Al Sharpton
    Rev. Jeremiah Wright
    Rev. Jese Jackson
    Rev. Jesse Jackson
    Rhodes Scholar
    Richard Dawkins
    Richard Painter
    Rick Gates
    Ridley Scott
    R.J. Matson
    Robert De Niro
    Robert Kennedy
    Robert Mueller
    Robin Hood
    Rob Reiner
    Rosa Parks
    Rosie Perez
    Rt.com
    Rush Limbaugh
    Russell Crowe
    Russia
    Russia Hoax
    Russian Collusion
    Ruth Ben-Ghiat
    Rwanda
    Samuel L. Jackson
    Sarah Palin
    Sarah Sanders
    School Choice
    Scott Ritter
    Sean Hannity
    Sen. Amy Klobuchar
    Sen. Bernie Sanders
    Sen. Elizabeth Warren
    Sen. Mazie Hirono
    Shameless
    Showtime
    Slayer
    Snapchat
    Socialism
    Sophia Bush
    South Chicago
    Southern Poverty Law Center
    Speaker Pelosi
    Spenser Susser
    Starbucks
    State Department
    Stephen King
    Stewart Lee
    St. Louis
    St. Louis Post Dispatch
    St. Louis Post-Dispatch
    St. Paul Public Schools
    Strzok Stroke Smirk
    Swiffer
    Sylvester Stallone
    Taliban
    Talk Of The Nation
    TDS
    Tea Party Republicans
    Terrence Howard
    The God Delusion
    The Hollywood Reporter
    The River Murders
    Tiffany Haddish
    Time Magazine
    Tim Keller
    "To Kill A Mockingbird"
    True Detective
    Trump Derangement Syndrome
    Ukraine
    Ukrainian Pres. Volodymyr Zelensky
    United Nations
    United State Constitution
    Unplanned
    U.S. Navy Reserve
    Van Jones
    Venezuela
    Violence In Football
    Vladimir Lenin
    Vladimir Putin
    Walmart
    Wash.
    Washington Post
    Webster
    Webster Central School District
    West Angeles Church Of God In Christ
    WHEC News
    White House
    William H. Macy
    Winston Churchill
    Woody Allen
    Woody Harrelson
    World Cup
    World Trade Center
    World Trade Organization
    WTO



    Archives

    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    September 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    February 2015
    November 2014
    December 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    September 2012
    July 2012
    May 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    November 2011
    September 2011
    March 2011
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    January 2010
    October 2009