ijiblog.net, by Larry Ingram, publishes media and news analysis

The Promise movie leaves audience without explanation for Muslim hate and Christian suffering

7/27/2017

 
"The Promise" is a simple movie similar to others that depict one of many examples of genocide since the world began. It’s a visually stunning and moving story set in Turkey, just before the outbreak of World War I. But it does not explain why there was a Armenian genocide in Turkey in the first place.
"The Promise" is a simple movie similar to others that depict one of many examples of genocide since the world began. It’s a visually stunning and moving story set in Turkey, just before the outbreak of World War I. But it does not explain why there was a Armenian genocide in Turkey in the first place. Why did the Turks so dislike the Armenians that they wanted to exterminate them? To understand that, one must understand the history of Islam and the Ottoman Empire. Without that knowledge, the movie is an attempt to provide meaning or purpose in suffering without a reason for the suffering.
It’s hard to see where the fault lies for leaving this out. It would have been easy for the producers to include links to the history of Turkey or the Ottoman Empire. Alas, it was left out. Even more, the director could have explained that the Turks were Muslim. What we are left with is a futile attempt to explain suffering by the director and a few famous actors - Terry George (director), Christian Bale, Chris Isaac and James Cromwell. All of the actors are famous in their own right. Perhaps it’s not their fault.
The movie itself has an effective story line: a man living in a small village in Armenia receives a dowry in return for a promise to marry a village woman so that he can pursue medical studies in Constantinople. While there, he falls in love with an attractive cosmopolitan Armenian woman, Ana. Though probably a Christian, Ana spent years studying in Paris, where she unlearned some of her Christian character. As a result, she is living, or having sex with a reporter stationed in Constantinople.
She then falls in love with another Michael (Chris Isaac), and has sex with him. The movie thus demonstrates a watered down Christian ethic that is common in Hollywood, one that ignores or trims the essence of Christianity. It would have been shocking for a Christian from an Armenian village to compromise his Christian character when he is promised by dowry to another woman. In fact, the story line is perhaps an insult to Armenians.
It also demonstrates a corrupting of the central message of the movie: that character matters. Again, it’s common for screenwriters and producers in Hollywood of whatever background, to misunderstand Christianity. Is this simply because Hollywood is devoid of Christians? Actors like Christian Bale or Chris Isaac don't have to understand what Christianity means. It's not part of their job. Unfortunately, Christianity and the resulting hope in the face of suffering is a central core of the movie. Christianity, or more specifically, what Jesus did on a cross, is what gave hope to Armenian Christians in the fact of suffering.
Here are some of the comments from interviews included in the DVD by George and some of the actors, with commentary:
George: “I told the story through the perspective of a love triangle, because I wanted to show ordinary people, when challenged, find greatness through their reaction to these catastrophic circumstances. If you are engaged in the dilemma between Chris and Michael and Ana, these are emotions that people can identify with. Then, as the genocide unfolds, we can see the effect on their own lives.”
Movie: Minister, you are using this so-called relocation as cover, for the systematic extermination of the Armenian people, says Henry Morganthou, ambassador from the U.S.
James Cromwell (Henry Morganthou):
“The story exemplifies the callousness, the crassness, the hardness of the Turkish position against the Armenian people.”
That’s an understatement. If a government decides to systematically kill millions of people in a country, it’s a lot worse than being crass, callous, or hard. Commercials are often crass. Deciding to kill a group of people is a lot worse than being crass. Genocide is evil; it’s horrific.
Bale: "If you don't learn from history, you are destined to repeat it."
Isaac: “These things keep happening over and over and over again, every day, in the same part of the world, with people fleeing for their lives, families asking the world to help and the world standing aloof.”
Isaac is obviously referring to killing of people in Syria and Iraq at the hands of ISIS. But ISIS is an attempt to recreate an Islamic caliphate that was the Ottoman empire. Turkey is what's left of the Ottoman Empire.
Much of the suffering that Isaac refers to is the result of inept decisions by former Pres. Barach Obama and former Sec. of State Hillary Clinton. Obama is also famous for his dismissive comments about ISIS.
Here is Ben Rhode’s (Obama’s go to scholar) explanation for Obama's comment:
"The president was responding very specifically to the geographic expansion of ISIL in Iraq and Syria," Rhodes said, using another acronym for the group. "A year ago, we saw them on the march in Iraq and Syria, taking more and more population centers. The fact is that we have been able to stop that geographic advance and take back significant amounts of territory in both northern Iraq and northern Syria. At the same time, that does not diminish the fact that there is a threat posed by ISIL, not just in those countries but in their aspirations to project power overseas."
Again, this is like saying Armenians would be safe from harm at the top of Mount Ararat. They were being killed, annihilated everywhere else. But if they were to reach the top of the mountain, with winter clothing and plenty of supplies to last a few years, they would be safe. It displays the same indifferent attitude described by Cromwell: indifferent to suffering and death.
There is another irony to Obama and ISIS. Obama was a vocal opponent to the Bush regime’s military action or invasion of Iraq. But he encouraged the Arab Spring in the Middle East. A major part of the Arab Spring was the overthrow of Mohammar Ghaddafi  Even the pro-Obama Newsweek magazine admits that Obama’s intervention in the Middle East was a fiasco. In fact, an article in the magazine says his actions were worse than stupid. Another article in the pro-Obama L.A. Times criticizes Obama's action in Syria as well.
Here is a quote from an Obama diplomat:
“A more democratic region will ultimately be more stable for us and our friends. Even if someone wants to be dictatorial, it’s going to be difficult.”
So said American diplomat Denis McDonough (Obama’s deputy national security adviser), after the overthrow of Qaddafi. If one can call ISIS dictatorial, it would be a walk in the park.
In a highly political and liberal Hollywood, any criticism of Obama by an actor, even though well-deserved, would result in being ostracized by Hollywood. Thus the actors (and director) issue weak opinions without historical impact. Issac refers to suffering in the Middle East without laying the blame at Obama's feet. He is right to leave Obama alone. He and Bale would not get another acting job in Hollywood were they to do so.
But back to Armenian movie and more quotes:
Bale: “Terry wanted everyone to are able to watch this without that grotesque violence being what they came away with.”
“I hope that there is a real social impact with this film. You want it to move you, you want to feel something. You want to think something that you haven’t thought before. You want a new experience. In terms of people involved in this film, I would absolutely believe that there is an eternal promise that they’ve made to their ancestors, not to forget.”
George: “It’s vital that people understand how these Armenian refugees managed to survive, that many of them died, that some of them escaped. Despite the attempt to wipe them out, they’ve continued to thrive and build and recreate the Armenian nation.”
Bale: “The Turkish government makes the decision to exterminate the Armenians."
George: “Part of the plan was for Armenian males to be shipped off to various labor camps. Michael finds himself in one of these labor camps.”
Terry wanted to find some of the human stories, Bale says. “They are trying to protect their families and the ones’ they love.”
All in all, it’s a movie that is certainly worth seeing. But without exploring the historical conflict between Christianity and Islam in the region, it’s not much more than another movie about suffering. The Muslims were a proud military force and empire in Ottoman, before World War I.
Here is some more historical context: During WWI, Serbia and Bulgaria plotted against the Ottoman Empire to take back territory from the Ottoman Empire, thus forcing them out of Greece. Turkey retains only an area surrounding Istanbul. As well, Britain and France, carved up the Ottoman Empire into countries that included Syria and Lebanon. 2012 was the hundred year anniversary of the demise of the Ottoman Empire. 
The effort by ISIL during and after the Obama administration is an effort to reclaim the military glory and power of the Ottoman Empire.
© 2017 Larry Ingram

Comments are closed.

    Based in St Louis,
    ​Larry Ingram writes about the news media, movies and culture, as well as topics like race, privilege, Christianity, religious expression and tolerance.

    Many news articles are blatantly biased against Christians and conservatives in the news media, movies and culture.

    Read his exclusive articles and columns that bring balance to mainstream, leftist and liberal thinking on a variety of topics.


    Categories

    All
    Aberdeen
    Abortion
    Abortion Laws
    Abortion Restrictions
    Abortion Rights
    Abraham Lincoln
    Acts 17 Apologetics
    Adolf Hitler
    Afghanistan
    A. G. Sulzberger
    Agxplore
    Alabama
    Alexandria Ocasio Cortez
    Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
    Alyssa Milano
    American Journal Of Public Health
    Ancient Greece
    Ann Coulter
    Antifa
    April Ryan
    Arlighton Senior High School
    Atty Gen. William Barr
    Avatar
    Baby Daddies
    Baltimore
    Barach Obama
    Bayshore Progressive Democrats
    Big Bang Theory
    Bill Clinton
    Bill Moyers Journal
    Bill Nye
    Bill O'Reilly
    Bill O'Reilly
    Biologos
    Black Actors
    Black Shirts
    Bob Costas
    Bob Ewell
    Bob Woodward
    Bosnians
    Brian Stelter
    Broad Comedy
    Bryan Burwell
    Capital One
    Carmen Twillie Ambar
    Catholic Church
    Celebrity Apprentice
    Charles Darwin
    Charlie Brennan
    Chicago Police Department
    Childhood
    Children
    China
    Chrissy Tiegen
    Christine Lahti
    Climate Change
    CNN
    College Athletes
    Communism
    Communist China
    Congressional Hearing
    Corey Lewandowski
    Creation Model
    Cruella De Vil
    C-Span.org
    Cuba
    Dan Rather
    Dave Checketts
    David Cay Johnson
    Dean Baquet
    Dearborn
    Democrat National Committee
    Democrat Party
    Democrats
    Denzel Washington
    Deontay Wilder
    Department Of Justice
    Detroit
    Diane Brayton
    Diversity
    DNC
    Donald J. Trump
    Donald Trump
    Donica Thomas Varner
    Don Lemon
    Doonesbury
    Dr. Bandy Lee
    Dr. Ben Carson
    Dr. Jeffrey Sachs
    Dr. Kermit Gosnell
    Dr. Laura Schlessinger
    Dr. Leana Wen
    Dr. Martin Luther King
    Drug Smuggling
    Emory University
    Empire
    Family Research Center
    FBI
    Federal Bureau Of Investigation
    Felicity Huffman
    Fire Fighters
    Fox News
    Fox News Channel
    France
    Frank Gallagher
    Fresno Bee
    Fusion GPS
    Gar Alperovitz
    Garry Trudeau
    George Takei
    German Workers' Party
    Gertrude Stein
    Gibson's Bakery
    Glenn Beck
    Glen Simpson
    "Glory Road"
    Gov. Bill Weld
    Gov. Jay Nixon
    Great New York State Fair
    Green New Deal
    Hajib
    Hamtramck
    Harold A. Schaitberger
    Harvard University
    Hawaii
    HBO
    Hesher
    Hillary Clinton
    Hollywood
    Hollywood Celebrities
    House Intelligence Committee
    House Judiciary Committee
    Howie Kurtz
    Human Origins
    Human Trafficking
    IAFF
    Ides Of March
    Illegal Immigration
    Immanuel Christian School
    Incest
    Inner City Pastors
    Intelligent Design
    International Association Of Fire Fighters
    International Olympic Committee
    Intolerance
    Iran
    Iranian Leaders
    IRS
    Islam
    Ivanka Trump
    Jackie Robinson
    Jack Jackson
    James Cameron
    James Clapper
    James Comey
    Jason Stanley
    Jeanine Pirro
    J. Edgar Hoover
    Jennifer Garner
    Jennifer Palmieri
    Jerrold Post
    Jim Acosta
    Jim Crow
    Joe Biden
    Johnathan Van Ness
    John Brennan
    John F. Kennedy
    John Hamburg
    John Legend
    John Podesta
    John Shore
    John Wells
    Joseph Mifsud
    Joseph Romm
    Jr.
    Juan Williams
    Jubaland
    Jubaland Foundation
    Judge Jeanine
    Judiciary Committee
    Jussie Smollett
    Justin Vail
    Karen Pence
    Katie Goodman
    Kelly Robinson
    Kendrick Sampson
    Kentucky
    Ken Vogel
    Kevin Hart
    KGB
    KMOX
    Kremlin
    Lake County
    Large Hadron Collider
    Laurence Fishburne
    Leftists
    Lennox Lewis
    Leonard Pitts Jr.
    Liberal Media
    Liberals
    Li Cunxin
    Life Recovery Bible
    Lil Uzi Vert
    Lisa Randall
    Loch Ness Monster
    Los Angeles
    Lutheran
    Lynne Patton
    Lyon
    Madden 20
    MAGA
    Make America Great Again
    Mao
    March Madness
    Marek Warszawski
    Marianne Williamson
    Martin Luther King
    Martin Sheen
    Matthew McConaughey
    Megadeath
    Mendi Hasan
    Meredith Kopit Levein
    Meredith Raimondo
    Metallica
    Methane
    Mexico
    Mexico Border Crisis
    Michele Reiner
    Micron
    Mike Pence
    Mimi Alford
    Minneapolis
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Missouri
    Morality In Media
    Motherf***er
    Movie Reviews
    MSNBC
    Mueller Report
    Muslim
    Muslims
    NAACP
    National Education Association
    National Press Club
    National Public Radio
    Natural Selection
    Nazi Party
    NCAA
    Neal Conan
    Nellie Ohr
    Nelson Mandela
    Netflix
    New Testament
    New York City
    New York Times
    NFL
    Nicholas Stoller
    Nigeria
    Nobel Peace Prize
    NoDoz
    North Korea
    Npr
    NY
    Obama Administration
    Oberlin College
    Osama Bin Laden
    Oval Office
    Pastor Zhang Bike Mingxuan
    Paul Mannafort
    Persecution In China
    Peter Strzok
    Philip Zimbardo
    Planned Parenthood
    Planned Parenthood Presidential Forum
    PostTraumatic Stress Disorder
    Pres. Donald Trump
    Pres. Kennedy
    Pro Abortion
    Procter & Gamble
    Profanity
    Pro-life
    PTSD
    Purple Heart
    Pyongyang
    Racist
    Radical Left
    Ray Liota
    Rebecca Parker Mankey
    Redeemer Presbyterian Church
    Rep. Adam Schiff
    Rep. Barnis Franke
    Rep. Charles Rangel
    Rep. Darryl Issa
    Rep. Devin Nunes
    Rep. Elijah Cummings
    Rep. Ilhan Omar
    Rep. Jamie Raskin
    Rep. Jerold Nadler
    Rep Jerrold Nadler
    Rep. John Radcliffe
    Rep. John Shimkus
    Rep. Ken Buck
    Rep. Mark Meadows
    Rep. Maxine Waters
    Rep. Nancy Pelosi
    Rep. Rashida Tlaib
    Reproductive Rights
    Rep. Shirley Jackson Lee
    Rep. Steve Cohen
    Rep. Steve Scalise
    Republicans
    Rev Al Sharpton
    Rev. Al Sharpton
    Rev. Jeremiah Wright
    Rev. Jese Jackson
    Rev. Jesse Jackson
    Rhodes Scholar
    Richard Dawkins
    Richard Painter
    Rick Gates
    Ridley Scott
    R.J. Matson
    Robert De Niro
    Robert Kennedy
    Robert Mueller
    Robin Hood
    Rob Reiner
    Rosa Parks
    Rosie Perez
    Rt.com
    Rush Limbaugh
    Russell Crowe
    Russia
    Russia Hoax
    Russian Collusion
    Ruth Ben-Ghiat
    Rwanda
    Samuel L. Jackson
    Sarah Palin
    Sarah Sanders
    School Choice
    Scott Ritter
    Sean Hannity
    Sen. Amy Klobuchar
    Sen. Bernie Sanders
    Sen. Elizabeth Warren
    Sen. Mazie Hirono
    Shameless
    Showtime
    Slayer
    Snapchat
    Socialism
    Sophia Bush
    South Chicago
    Southern Poverty Law Center
    Speaker Pelosi
    Spenser Susser
    Starbucks
    State Department
    Stephen King
    Stewart Lee
    St. Louis
    St. Louis Post Dispatch
    St. Louis Post-Dispatch
    St. Paul Public Schools
    Strzok Stroke Smirk
    Swiffer
    Sylvester Stallone
    Taliban
    Talk Of The Nation
    TDS
    Tea Party Republicans
    Terrence Howard
    The God Delusion
    The Hollywood Reporter
    The River Murders
    Tiffany Haddish
    Time Magazine
    Tim Keller
    "To Kill A Mockingbird"
    True Detective
    Trump Derangement Syndrome
    Ukraine
    Ukrainian Pres. Volodymyr Zelensky
    United Nations
    United State Constitution
    Unplanned
    U.S. Navy Reserve
    Van Jones
    Venezuela
    Violence In Football
    Vladimir Lenin
    Vladimir Putin
    Walmart
    Wash.
    Washington Post
    Webster
    Webster Central School District
    West Angeles Church Of God In Christ
    WHEC News
    White House
    William H. Macy
    Winston Churchill
    Woody Allen
    Woody Harrelson
    World Cup
    World Trade Center
    World Trade Organization
    WTO



    Archives

    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    September 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    February 2015
    November 2014
    December 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    September 2012
    July 2012
    May 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    November 2011
    September 2011
    March 2011
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    January 2010
    October 2009